How the Lawyers Stole Winter

By Chris Daly

By popular demand, I am re-posting the following essay I wrote, which is about skating on ponds outside Boston when I was a kid. Every winter, I get asked about it, and I am delighted to share it. The essay was originally published in The Atlantic in March, 1995 (just before the point at which the magazine arbitrarily decided to start routinely putting its contents online). It has also been anthologized in several “readers” intended to help high school and college-age students learn to write essays. It also used to appear on my old blog, but when I switched blog hosts last year, my old content did not follow into my new home. Thus, it is impossible to find a complete copy on the Web.

So, here goes:



Pond skating in the changed context of childhood

By Christopher B. Daly

© 1995


When I was a boy, my friends and I would come home from school each day, change our clothes (because we were not allowed to wear “play clothes” to school) and go outside until dinnertime. In the early 1960s in Medford, a city on the outskirts of Boston, that was pretty much what everybody did. Sometimes, there might be flute lessons or an organized Little League game, but usually not. Usually, we kids went out and played.

In winter, on our way home from the Gleason School, we usually went past Brooks Pond to check the ice. By throwing heavy stones onto it, hammering it with downed branches and, finally, jumping on it, we could figure out if the ice was ready for skating. If it was, we would hurry home, grab our skates, our sticks, and whatever other gear we had, and then return to play hockey for the rest of the day. When the streetlights came on, we knew it was time to jam our cold, stiff feet back into our green rubber snow boots and get home for dinner.

I had all these memories in mind recently when I moved, with my wife and our two young boys, into a house near a lake even closer to Boston, in the city of Newton. As soon as Crystal Lake froze over, I grabbed my skates and headed out. I was not the first one there, though: the lawyers had beaten me to the lake. They had warned the town Recreation Department to put it off limits. So I found a sign that said:






Knowing a thing or two about words myself, I put my own gloss on the sign. I took it to mean, When the ice is thin, then there is danger, and there should be no skating.

Fair enough, I thought, but I knew that the obverse was also true: When the ice is thick, then it is safe, and there should be skating.

Finding the ice plenty thick, I laced up my skates and glided out onto the miraculous glassy surface of a frozen lake. My wife, a native of Manhattan, would not let me take our two boys with me. But for as long as I could, I enjoyed the free, open-air delight of skating as it should be. After a few days, others joined me, and we became an outlaw band of skaters.

What we were doing was once the heart of winter in New England – and a lot of other places, too. It was clean, free exercise that needed no Stairmasters, no health clubs, no appointments, and hardly any gear. Sadly, it is in danger of passing away. Nowadays it seems that every city and town and almost all property holders are so worried about liability and lawsuits that they simply throw up a sign or a fence and declare that henceforth there shall be no skating, and that’s the end of it.

As a result, kids today live in a world of leagues, rinks, rules, uniforms, adults, and rides – rides here, rides there, rides everywhere. It is not clear that they are better off, and in some ways they are clearly not better off.


*      *     *

When I was a boy skating on Brooks Pond, there were no grown-ups around. Once or twice a year, on a weekend day or a holiday, some parents might come by, with a thermos of hot cocoa. Maybe they would build a fire — which we were forbidden to do — and we would gather round.

But for the most part the pond was the domain of children. In the absence of adults, we made and enforced our own rules. We had hardly any gear – just some borrowed hockey gloves, some hand-me-down skates, maybe an elbow pad or two – so we played a clean form of hockey, with no high-sticking, no punching, and almost no checking. A single fight could ruin the whole afternoon. Indeed, as I remember it 30 years later, it was the purest form of hockey I ever saw – until I got to see the Russian national team play the game.

But before we could play, we had to check the ice. We became serious junior meteorologists, true connoisseurs of cold. We learned that the best weather for pond skating is plain, clear cold, with starry nights and no snow. (Snow not only mucks up the skating surface but also insulates the ice from the colder air above.) And we learned that moving water, even the gently flowing Mystic River, is a lot less likely to freeze than standing water. So we skated only on the pond. We learned all the weird whooping and cracking sounds that ice makes as it expands and contracts, and thus when to leave the ice.

Do kids learn these things today? I don’t know. How would they? We don’t even let them. Instead, we post signs. Ruled by lawyers, cities and towns everywhere try to eliminate their legal liability. But try as they might, they cannot eliminate the underlying risk. Liability is a social construct; risk is a natural fact. When it is cold enough, ponds freeze. No sign or fence or ordinance can change that.

In fact, by focusing on liability and not teaching our kids how to take risks, we are making their world more dangerous. When we were children, we had to learn to evaluate risks and handle them on our own. We had to learn, quite literally, to test the waters. As a result, we grew up to be more savvy about ice and ponds than any kid could be who has skated only under adult supervision on a rink.

When I was a boy, despite the risks we took on the ice no one I knew ever drowned. The only people I ever heard about who drowned were graduate students at Harvard or MIT who came from the tropics who were living through their first winters. Not knowing about how ice forms on moving water (After all, how could they?), they would innocently venture out onto the half-frozen Charles River, fall through, and die. They were literally out of their element.

Are we raising a generation of children who will be out of their element? And if so, what can we do about it? We cannot just roll back the calendar. I cannot tell my six-year-old to head down to the lake by himself to play all afternoon – if for no other reason, he will not find twenty or thirty other kids there, full of the collective wisdom about cold and ice that they have inherited from their older brothers and sisters. Somewhere along the line that link got broken.

The whole setting of childhood has changed. We cannot change it again overnight. I cannot send them out by themselves yet, but at least some of the time, I can go out there with them. Maybe that is a start.


*       *      *


As for us, last winter was a very unusual one. We had ferocious cold (near-zero temperatures on many nights) and tremendous snows (about a hundred inches in all). Eventually a strange thing happened. The city gave in – sort of. Sometime in January, the recreation department “opened” a section of the lake, and even dispatched a snowplow truck to clear a good-sized patch of ice. I brought the boys, and we skated the rest of winter. Ever vigilant, the city officials kept the “Thin Ice” signs up, even though their own truck could safely drive on the frozen surface. And they brought in “lifeguards” and all sorts of rules about the hours we could skate and where we had to stay.

But at least we were able to skate in the open air, on real ice.

And it was still free.






[© copyright by Christopher B. Daly. To re-publish, contact the author:

First published in The Atlantic Monthly in March 1995]



Filed under Boston, history

15 responses to “How the Lawyers Stole Winter

  1. Carrie

    Oh my goodness! I grew up skating on Hammond Pond in Chestnut Hill. It never crossed my mind that this innocent and delightful pastime might now be a thing of the past.:-( Miraculously, my friends and I also survived some occasional forbidden forays out onto the precarious slabs of saltwater ice (how was that even possible?!) that rimmed the bay in Duxbury. Living now in California, these are adventures my own successfully-grown children have never known, and more’s the pity.

    A beautiful piece, Chris — and for me at least, evocative of many happy memories. Thanks for that!


  2. Skate or die!

    I was still in my early teens when the original article was published. I’m a pond skater from a long line of devoted pond skaters, and right around ’95, my town saw a couple of warm winters without good ice. In 1993, skating on the pond was something everyone did.

    In 1996, it was illegal, and no one could say HOW the change had come to be. I was kicked off by the police repeatedly. On one memorable occasion, standing on ice thick enough to drive on, possibly so thick the shallow pond had truly frozen solid, a cop actually told me, straight-faced, that it wasn’t safe yet.

    My family still practices civil disobedience on that same pond. Winter lives!


  3. I love this essay, and have used it in my Developmental English classes. Just discovered it here because I was chatting with a friend on Facebook who wants to put real candles on his Christmas tree this year, but after some Googling, he only came up with one company in Germany that sells them. (There were, however, other sites selling LED “candles.”) Made me think of this essay, which I then mentioned to him; he asked for a copy, and voila! I landed here. Just in case you were wondering.


  4. brandy

    a wonderful essay chris. I grew up in the 60’s and 70’s and skating was my hobby all the time. Thanks for sharing that.


  5. Jeremiah Downing

    My wife and I just had an argument over our 12 yr old boy. We live in a sub division with 1 entrance and 0 crime and our boy wanted a ride to his friends house 3 blocks away at 6pm on a 75 degree day. I said walk and she said she would give him a ride after feeding the baby. Anyways, I insisted he walked. She got mad at me while he stomped out of the house. After her being pissed at me for some time I remembered this essay from English comp 1 class. I looked it up online and read it to her, then said “that’s all I’m saying”. We reconciled and things are fine. Great essay and so true



  6. Renee

    I love this essay! I was always used to skating at the rink in my town here in New York, but every once in a while during the winter my backyard freezes, Even skating in my own backyard is much more pleasant, and real than the rink. I hope when I grow up my kids will skate in their backyards too.


  7. Paul Donovan

    I don’t know if you will get this Chris, given the time that has passed since you posted this.
    An old timer, whom I met yesterday skating on a pond in Freeport, ME told me about a story of pond skating in Medford that he had read. He sent it to me last night.
    It’s a small world. I hope this finds you well. And, I hope you are still getting out on the ponds.
    Your very old friend,
    Paul Donovan

    PS I could see in my mind’s eye you, Trav, and crew all those years ago.


    • profdaly

      Hey, Paul!

      Great to hear from you, after so many years. I’m doing great — been on the faculty at BU for almost 25 years now. I love teaching and writing, so it’s a sweetspot.

      Thanks for reading my essay. I still get to skate sometimes, but not nearly enough. And with these warmer winters, it seems rarer and rarer that we have “good ice” in greater Boston.

      Are you living in Maine? Who was that old-timer?

      Hope you are healthy and well.



  8. Alison

    I use this in my 7th grade classroom along with the book The Giver. Such a great example of how we are heading towards that same type of society. A friend read it to us in a car on a ski trip the same year it was published and I never forgot it. Spent a few years searching for it (for some reason I thought it was in The New Yorker) and was so happy to find it. It produces some great discussions.


    • profdaly

      Thank you so much for this kind note. As a teacher myself, I know how wonderful it is to find just what you are looking for class. I don’t imagine that there is much pond skating around Tucson, but I hope your students can picture it!

      Be well. Do good.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s